Opinion

Carney: Cherry? Students see red

It’s hard to define the “cherry” in “Cherry and White.”

Michael CarneyThere has been considerable talk recently about Temple’s construction projects, the safety on Main Campus and the university’s budget, but students and faculty are ignoring the real issue of this semester: Cherry and white are Temple’s official school colors, yet the university fails to specify which particular species of cherry it uses. Is Temple referring to a blood-red Montmorency, a merlot Bing or some shade in between?

Temple’s cherry problem caught my attention about a week ago while I found myself looking toward campus from my window on the 21st floor of Morgan Hall North. I saw painters creating the giant Temple “T” on the roof of the Liacouras Center; undoubtedly an effort to expand Temple’s already massive advertising campaign to airline passengers. However, just beneath the roof, a ribbon of red paint around the building was an entirely different shade of red, and the flags that line Broad Street were yet another.

But the variety of colors does not stop there.

A glance around campus reveals at least five contradictory shades of red, while a quick perusal of the merchandise at the university bookstore reveals about another eight.

The Student Center itself is painted what many would consider red in its most traditional sense. Yet that same Student Center sells burgundy-colored pennants and T-shirts in every shade of red conceivable. The “T” depicted on the university’s main website is red but noticeably different in shade than that of the “T” depicted on Temple’s Diamond Dollars website. Both of these “T”’s differ in hue from the “T” on the website of the Beasley School of Law.

These blatant discrepancies have been largely ignored by the Temple community. Students must question the legitimacy of a university that cannot pass elementary art class. Where will it go from here? Can Temple be trusted to hire faculty? To serve food?

I find it suspicious that many of these exotic shades of red are appearing immediately after our 10th president was inaugurated. President Theobald formerly worked as the senior vice president and chief financial officer of Indiana University. It is not a coincidence that Indiana’s school colors are crimson and cream. Not only has President Theobald implemented the same financial policies at Temple as he did at Indiana, but he is trying to assimilate us chromatically by gradually moving the university toward a more crimson shade of cherry.

The concept of school colors began with practicality in mind. One of the earliest implementations of school colors occurred at Harvard University during the 1850s when two rowers provided crimson-colored bandanas to the rowing team to make them easily identifiable to Harvard fans at the banks of the river. Eventually, school colors came to represent a university as a whole and encouraged school spirit. School colors have lost much of their meaning in recent years, slowly marching down the capitalist path of merchandise sales and brand recognition.

On Feb. 27, 2008, University Communications announced that Temple would designate the online hex color code #9E1B34 as the official shade of cherry. However, the announcement states that “new work products should use the new official color, but it is permissible to exhaust existing supplies that use other colors.” Evidently, this policy has either not yet been completely adopted or Temple still hasn’t run out of buckets of paint from five years ago.

During her term, President Ann Weaver Hart oversaw the publication of Temple’s “Graphic Identity Standards,” a 32-page document detailing specifications for official colors, logos and stationery, among other things. The document frequently mentions the color “Temple red,” which differs from cherry. Even the document designed to unify Temple’s colors fails to accurately declare our colors cherry and white. In fact, the word “cherry” is only used once in the document, while “red” is used 16 times.

The cherry problem is not unique to Temple. The University of Pennsylvania’s official colors are blue and red, but its online apparel store sells clothing ranging from traditional blue to navy blue. Drexel University’s colors are blue and gold and share the same variety of blues as Penn. Almost every U.S. university has some type of guidelines for what shade of a particular color should be used to represent the school, from Texas A&M University’s “Brand Colors,” to – my favorite – Stanford University’s “Identity Toolkit.” Although these universities develop detailed color and formatting guidelines, few schools consistently follow these rules.

The only solution to the cherry problem is to change our school colors entirely. Might I suggest gray and white to represent Temple’s world-renowned squirrels? Baker Dave’s red velvet cookies would be no more, and any color change would require switching the cherry and white mentioned in our fight song to whichever colors we choose, although this would not be too significant of a change since this is typically sung during touchdowns.

Michael Carney can be reached at michael.carney@temple.edu.

Latest posts by Michael Carney (see all)

    One comment on “Carney: Cherry? Students see red

    1. The graphic and branding standards document that was put in place to make the Temple brand more consistent across proceeding print and web, but it is not retroactive unfortunately. And you’re right, some of the older websites don’t follow these standards. The problem here isn’t a consistency, but rather the university’s department of branding doesn’t necessarily have the means to take control of these sub domains and make the graphic changes. Besides, an undertaking like this would be incredibly expensive and time-consuming. So the focus is solely on the future and Temple has been doing an outstanding job in this regard. Find me a website constructed in the last year or so that doesn’t follow the standards. You can’t.

      There have been more focus by the administration to wrangle these smaller websites and make them more consistent but don’t expect anything soon. But I can assure you that from now on, #9E1B34 will be the primary cherry red on the web.

      Another thing you need to understand is that the colors in print, paint and pixels are all going to vary to some degree. Which is why you see so much inconsistency off the web. You can’t merely convert #9E1B34 into a paint color and have it look the same on screens, print and everything else. Granted, this variance doesn’t account for the wide array of cherry red that exists on campus and in the book store. The bigger contributor to the variance are the cherry red products that make up our campus come from hundreds of vendors across hundreds of industries. So having our vendors keep them consistent is unreasonable.

      But to me, none of this matters because cherry is a vague color anyway. We should keep it consistent when we can, such as web and print, but I can see it taking too much effort to make it consistent across the board.

      I hope you’re kidding when you say that the only reasonable suggestion is to change our colors. I won’t waste my time on explaining why this is so dumb.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    *

    * Copy This Password *

    * Type Or Paste Password Here *

    862,355 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

    You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>