Derailed DREAM Act fuels student voice for immigration

Temple for a DREAM members continue to fight for and raise awareness about the DREAM Act. Pamela Salazar was the valedictorian of her middle school, graduated in the Top 5 percent of Central High School

Temple for a DREAM members continue to fight for and raise awareness about the DREAM Act.

Pamela Salazar was the valedictorian of her middle school, graduated in the Top 5 percent of Central High School and will be graduating from Temple in a few months with two majors and two minors. But there’s a catch: She isn’t in the country legally.

Salazar is one of an approximate 12 million undocumented people in the United States. She’s also one of the estimated 65,000 undocumented students who graduate from high school in the U.S. each year who have lived in the country for at least five years.

Julia Freedman, co-founder of Temple for a DREAM, discusses upcoming plans for the organization at a meeting on Feb. 21. WALBERT YOUNG TTN

Salazar, 21, was brought here from Bolivia by her parents in December 1989, when she was eight months old. Therefore, she also would have been a beneficiary of the Development, Relief and Education of Alien Minors, or DREAM Act, which was struck down in a 55-41 senate vote in December.

Although the act passed by a vote of 216-to-198 in the House of Representatives, the bill would have needed the support of 60 senators to pass.

The act was designed to allow undocumented immigrants who entered the country as children to be put on a path toward citizenship.

Under its requirements, the DREAM Act would benefit those meeting all of the following criteria: are between the ages of 12 and 35 at the time of application; entered the U.S. before the age of 16; lived in the U.S. for five-consecutive years; graduated high school, obtained a General Educational Development diploma or been accepted into an institute of higher education; be of good moral character.

Salazar, a Spanish and information science and technology major who meets those requirements, isn’t giving up on her hope to become a U.S. citizen just yet.


Salazar, with the help of Julia Freedman, a theater and Spanish major, founded the student organization Temple for a DREAM in Fall 2010.

While the lame-duck session was in tact, Temple for a DREAM members wore graduation gowns at the Bell Tower, asking Temple students to call politicians and urge their support of the DREAM Act.

Now, the organization is focusing on educating students about immigration and the DREAM Act. In mid-March, Temple for a DREAM will take part in a “coming out” week initiated by several organizations across the country dedicated to the undocumented youth population.

Organizations, such as the Immigrant Youth Justice League and, encourage undocumented youth to take part in activist movements.

The IYJL declared March 10 “National Coming out of the Shadows Day” and has planned a rally in Chicago. The organization is pushing for actions across the country to take place on this date and during the following week.

Temple for a DREAM is planning to assist in a rally or event in Philadelphia during the week of March 14, Salazar said.

Although many undocumented students have publicly announced their illegal status in advocating for the DREAM Act, some credit sympathy and the Obama administration for law enforcement agencies not cracking down on the deportation of the noncitizen students.

“The administration has a tremendous amount of discretion in the enforcement of immigration law,” said Peter Spiro, a professor who teaches immigration law and international law. “From an enforcement perspective, it doesn’t make sense to go after highly sympathetic noncitizens such as the students that are publicly coming out as undocumented.”

“I think they can come out with some assurance that it’s not going to result in their removal,” Spiro said, adding that agencies are more likely to go after undocumented people engaging in criminal activity.

Spiro credited this, in part, to the “mismatch” between the estimated 12 million undocumented people and the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which currently employs more than 20,000 people.

In June 2010, Eric Balderas, an undocumented Harvard student, was detained after trying to board an airplane. He was later released and granted permission to stay in the U.S. to finish his studies, as well as apply for a work permit.

“I think if you get a high-profile case like [Balderas’] in which the government backed down, that’s an informal kind of precedent,” Spiro said.

The government tends to enforce immigration laws more vigilantly in areas of the country in which anti-immigration sentiments are stronger, Spiro added.

“In Philadelphia in particular, there’s not a lot of visible anti-immigration sentiment, so there’s not a lot of visible anti-immigration enforcement here,” Spiro said.

Still, Spiro likened the risks of deportation to that of a lightening strike, noting that law enforcement of immigration laws can be unpredictable.

If deported, Salazar said she would be in “complete shock [and] scared.”

“I would be more scared for my parents than for myself,” Salazar said. “If it happens to me, I’ll fight it.”


While Temple for a DREAM and other proponents of the DREAM Act continue to push for the act to be passed, Spiro said he’s not optimistic its enactment will come any time soon.

“Even in a case where the noncitizens involved are highly sympathetic, as is the case with the DREAM Act beneficiaries, it’s just unacceptable to those who are opposed to anything that’s [related to] amnesty,” Spiro said.

“The hopes were that the DREAM Act could go through with stand-alone legislation, apart from any comprehensive immigration reform,” Spiro added. “I’m not optimistic that there are any good prospects for enacting this legislation in the short term.”

“Some [opponents of the act] were trying to rename this the ‘Nightmare Act,’” Spiro said.

In the meantime, Salazar said undocumented people continue to be subject to exploitation.

“You have these lawyers here that just basically exploit you for money. They make you pay for applications that they don’t even carry out,” Salazar said. She added that this was the case for her family, who contacted a lawyer after reaching the U.S. to look into ways to become legal citizens.

Another challenge affecting undocumented students, Salazar said, is support, or lack thereof, from high school counselors.

Salazar said her first high school counselor said he couldn’t help her apply to college, so she eventually switched to a different counselor who was more helpful.

These challenges are in addition to constant fear of being found out, Salazar said.

Salazar said she didn’t know she was undocumented until she was in fifth grade, when her brother needed a social security number to apply to college. She said her brother became a “different person” after learning of his undocumented status.

“He felt stuck. He hit a wall,” Salazar said. “He was just so depressed, and he would lash out against my parents.”

Salazar said that after learning of her status and about deportation and immigration laws during a class in sixth grade, she no longer wanted to make new friends.

“At that moment, I completely became shy, introverted. I didn’t want to stick out anymore,” Salazar said. “I knew I looked different, but I didn’t want to stick out in any other way.”

To help current high school students, Salazar said she and members of Temple for a DREAM are working on outreach opportunities to help inform high school students of their options and offer support.


As Salazar’s future remains up in the air, she said she fears her education may be meaningless.

“I’ve worked so hard, and it’s sad to think that maybe all my hard work will not be paying off,” Salazar said. “Although I will have my degree in my hand, and although I have worked so hard throughout all my years of studies, it will mean nothing because I can’t apply for jobs like a normal person can.”

“As of right now, I’m just taking it day by day and enjoying my Temple time,” Salazar added. “I’m just seeing what I can do, [doing] volunteer work to get experience.”

In the meantime, Temple for a DREAM is looking to work with larger organizations, such as, Salazar said.

“When you find people that are just like you, you feel like you have support,” Salazar said. “You don’t feel like you’re a stranger anymore.”

Temple for a DREAM is also trying to connect with student organizations of similar interests, as well as with faculty, Freedman said.

Megan Chialastri, the president of Temple College Democrats and a senior political science major, said her organization has worked informally with Temple for a DREAM.

In Fall 2009, the TCD sponsored a resolution with Temple Student Government supporting the DREAM Act and the students “who struggle to achieve the dream of higher education,” because of status.

The resolution requested that copies of the resolution be forwarded to President Ann Weaver Hart, among other administrators.

But Salazar said she wants to see public support from Hart.

“It would be great if [Hart] would come out with full support [of the DREAM Act] and write to Congressmen,” Salazar said. “We want her to be a leader.”

“I think it would be great if Ann Weaver Hart could listen to that voice from the students and help to amplify it and make it even louder,” Chialastri said.

Support from fellow organizations and faculty members could also be helpful in making this happen, Freedman said.

In the past, presidents at universities across the country, including University of Pennsylvania President Amy Gutmann, have signed letters requesting political support of the DREAM Act.

“Any supportive statements from persons of stature, institutional leaders and others who are [prominent] are helpful,” Spiro said. “I’m not sure how well they balance against anti-immigrant sentiment in the electorate. Legislators who are looking at this issue are mostly looking at their constituents’ preferences on the issue.”

Spiro said presidents’ supporting of the DREAM Act is likely more meaningful to the undocumented students at the universities.

“That’s important because it shows institutional solidarity, and it reflects an inclusive sentiment on the part of the leadership of the institutional community,” Spiro said. “When you get presidents coming out in support of the DREAM Act it, in effect, is saying ‘you’re one of us, and we’re with you.’”

Angelo Fichera can be reached at


  1. “I’ve worked so hard, and it’s sad to think that maybe all my hard work will not be paying off,” Salazar said. “Although I will have my degree in my hand, and although I have worked so hard throughout all my years of studies, it will mean nothing because I can’t apply for jobs like a normal person can.”

    If Ms. Salazar had bothered to apply for a foreign student visa, which she could do before age 19 without facing the bar, Ms. Salazar would have been able to apply for a company to sponsor her. As it is, she herself CHOSE her illegal status at age 18. Nothing in this story explains why SHE is “special” compared with the 691,000 LEGAL foreign students in this country.

  2. This was an excellent story and I am glad that it finally got some attention.

    And the above comment is unfair. Ms Salazar is the voice for all those undocumented students in this country and her story is special because she had the courage to speak out about it. How many students know about the ‘foreign student visa?’ Her high school guidance counselor did not mention it, rather as it says in the paper, “he couldn’t help her her apply to college.” I am not an undocumented student, however I do understand their struggles and the fact that the contribute to this country just as American citizens do and should not face such circumstances.

  3. Ali–

    Because of changes in immigration law in the past fifteen years, Ms. Salazar in fact would not be authorized to apply for a student visa at the age of 18, but would be instead expected to turn to her country of origin and, after a ten year waiting period, she would then be allowed to request an application for entry into the United States from the US embassy in that country (which may or may not be granted).

    This policy was designed to be punitive rather than to address the real problem here–which is the presence of hundreds of thousands undocumented immigrants in this country. All it results in is thousands of students, each one of them as American in heart and ambition as Ms. Salazar (and some of whom have married Americans and are raising American children), having no realistic way to normalize their status and become fully integrated into American society–to have the chance to give back as all citizens are expected to, and as they desire to. What we then have is a second-class of citizens, permanently barred from having political representation, security in their own homes, and fair wages and working conditions.

    Think of the earning power of students like Ms. Salazar. Granting work authorization for these educated immigrants would enable them to contribute their talents to educated professions, and their increased earning power through taxes. Many of them may even start businesses: the self-drive and hard work that the act of migration self-selects for is precisely the personality profile that has powered the American economy since the very beginning.

    The DREAM Act was intended to fix this loophole in immigration law, so that children would be able to apply for their own status, instead of being undocumented for life through no actions of their own. Ali, this sounds like what you were suggesting, when you said Ms. Salazar should get a student visa. The DREAM Act is the solution, but unfortunately the influx of misinformation this past fall and harsh, divisive rhetoric resulted in many Americans not understanding that this is what the purpose of the DREAM Act was.

    I support the work of Temple for a DREAM and all other organizations like it. Keep fighting, and like other movements for justice in the past, through hard work and getting your stories out there, you will see your dreams come true.

  4. Help fight illegal immigration. Visit the websites for xNumbersUSAx and xALIPACx. We need federal E-Verify legislation.

  5. I have studied what it takes to become legal and have written many papers on what has changed and what should change about the process of becoming “legal” and even though I was always told it only takes one person to make a difference (which I do still believe for the most part) it really is hard because we have ignorant people out there like Ali and magyart who dont seem to really know what is going on and just say oh they are said to be illegal so we don’t need them well in this situation ms salazar is just as legal as any other American because at 8 months old she didn’t have a choice there is no way she could have gone back to her country and lived or.even survived you know and what about those children that are born here and never knew their parents arrived illegally these kids know nothing about the country their parents came from they know America because they are American Pete not blame children for parents mistakes. There is a lot more underneath the surface of every immigration story than what meets the eye. And remember even though they USED to have a choice at 18 don’t mean they knew when someone says oh your illegal what kid is going to blurted that out and ask questions how to change that status? I mean really if I heard that I would be scared and cautious with all the steps take I commend ms. Salazar for her efforts in making a change and willingness to voice her story

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.