Temple students question campus’ narrative of diversity

Students and faculty weigh in on how attending a predominantly white institution can impact students of color.

Maheen Shafi decided to come to Temple University to be among a more diverse crowd. But after two years at the university, the senior neuroscience major found herself disappointed.

“I realized that by the end of my sophomore year, I was still surrounded in this largely white space because so much of Temple University is large white spaces,” Shafi said. “And so for me to break out of that, I had to specifically seek out pockets of non-white spaces.”

Temple is a predominantly white institution, meaning white students make up 50 percent or more of the student body, according to the Encyclopedia of African American Education. Fifty-five percent of Temple undergraduates for the 2019-20 school year are non-Hispanic white, according to university research on 2019-2020 enrollment. 

On Aug. 19, Temple announced that 40 percent of this year’s freshman class are students of color. Yet Lindsey Farrell, a senior political science major, is skeptical that this announcement is nothing more than marketing.

“Yeah, you can have a bunch of people of color in your freshman class, but does that mean that they’re actually going to have any influence or power in any decisions that happen in their classes?” Farrell said. “No, professors are still going to be able to do whatever they want with them. They’re still going to be able to make them feel ostracised, subject them to racism and microaggressions and things like that.”

For the past four years, the university reported a 55 percent white undergraduate enrollment rate, which is a small decrease from the 2014-2015 school year, when Temple reported a 57 percent rate, according to the Office of Institutional Research and Assessment.

Kimberly Goyette, chair of the sociology department, feels that Temple has not always been seen as PWI, but the changing perception might be negatively affecting non-white students. 

“I think this is a shift in how Temple is perceived, which certainly affects the student body, as an institution which has had a perception of being one of the more diverse institutions, it does shift that and perhaps in ways that feel less comfortable for students of color,” Goyette said.

Valerie Harrison, the senior advisor to President Richard Englert for equity, diversity and inclusion, believes a PWI can still provide a culturally relevant and affirming experience for students of color.

Temple is surrounded by Black history: the Church of the Advocate on Diamond Street near 18th housed the Black Panther National convention in 1970, and the Universal Negro Improvement Association’s Philadelphia division is currently located on Cecil. B. Moore Avenue, Harrison said.

“There’s all of this rich history and culture that is right here, so going to a predominantly white institution, but one like Temple, can still offer you a culturally relevant experience,” she added.

Farrell feels it is not enough for the university to have racial equity committees or commit to having a diverse faculty and staff. 

“Of course there’s the argument of representation and there are some people of color on the Board of Trustees and some people of color in power at Temple, but that doesn’t mean that they’re actually conscious of the power that they hold and it doesn’t mean that they’re actually trying to make a change for students,” Farrell said.


  1. What a bunch of whiners and snowflakes. The world is not tailored to your expectations, so you might as well get used to it. Or you can live and get your education where you are a majority.

    • Exactly, these people are just plain sad. I can’t even fathom how awful it must be to walk around every day thinking of everything in terms of race, and dividing your fellow students into arbitrary tribes based on their skin color. I thought we didn’t stand for racism at Temple, this is clearly racism.

  2. This is the most pathetic drivel I ever had the displeasure reading. For starters, imagine being so caught up with being “anti-racist” that your primary concern is to, and I quote, “specifically seek out pockets of non-white spaces.”

    Imagine being so concerned with the color of peoples’ skin, that the only thing you can see at Temple University is its white students. This Maheen Shafi should really be ashamed of their caucasian-phobia.

    I also scoffed at what Lindsey Farell had to say. “No, professors are still going to be able to do whatever they want with them. They’re still going to be able to make them feel ostracised, subject them to racism and microaggressions and things like that.” Um… yes, that is how classrooms work sweetie. You don’t get to telly our professors what to do just because you are a BIPOC, just like the white students don’t either.

    Quit the whining and complaining. This is a university. There are going to be white people. Get over it.

  3. Shafi came for the diversity. Forty percent of the student body is white. So sixty percent is minority. Its much more diverse that the general population. So Maheen, how much is good enough for you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.